Research Shows Chemically Unique Metal-poor Stars Across the Milky Way Born in the Same Smaller Galaxies

Milky Way

The Milky Way. Credit: Adiv González Muñoz

By Deanna Csomo McCoolOriginally published at by the Notre Dame College of Science

Some of the rarest of stars found in the halo of the Milky Way -- stars enhanced by a set of reactions called the rapid neutron-capture process, or r-process -- have a shared chemical history and were likely “born” in the same small parent galaxy, a recent study by University of Notre Dame researchers and collaborators has shown.

The discovery, published recently in The Astrophysical Journal, came after compiling information gathered through an alliance of astronomers who discovered 446 metal-poor stars with characteristic signatures of the r-process elements in spectra obtained with an armada of telescopes – from moderate- to large-aperture  -- along with sophisticated dynamical clustering algorithms.

Energy-Angular Momentum plots
Energy-Angular Momentum plots of the locations of r-process-enhanced stars that share similar orbits in the Milky Way, indicating that the stars in each identified group (same symbol and color) were born in individual low-mass galaxies.  Otherwise, stars with the same colors/symbols would appear randomly distributed in these plots.

The research team, which included Notre Dame Professor Timothy Beers and former research assistant professor Vinicius Placco, in addition to Dmitrii Gudin (the paper’s lead author) ‘20Ph.D, Erika Holmbeck ‘20Ph.D., Sarah Dietz ‘20Ph.D., K. Rasmussen ‘20Ph.D.,  and doctoral candidate Derek Shank, along with other collaborators, identified 30 groups of r-process-enhanced stars having very similar orbits in the Milky Way, indicating they were once members of low-mass galaxies that were later disrupted into the halo of the Galaxy.

Just as someone trained in accident reconstruction can determine the make and model of a destroyed vehicle by recovery and analysis of small parts and pieces, the research team pieced together bits of cosmic information to make their discovery. Combined with data from the European Gaia satellite, which makes high-precision geometric measurements of stellar distances as well as their angular motions across the sky, the researchers were able to calculate the orbits of the individual stars.  They discovered that the elemental abundances of the stars in each dynamical group are statistically much more similar to one another than would be expected from chance. This allowed the team to claim that the stars in these groups shared the same chemical history, or “birthplace.”

"In this paper, we wanted to demonstrate that we could show that at least some, perhaps all, of these r-process-enhanced stars came from low-mass galaxies where they were born,” Beers said. “It turns out that there are one or two still intact dwarf galaxies where we actually have seen r-process-enhanced stars.  However, many other such small galaxies must have been destroyed during the Milky Way’s history in order to account for the numbers of r-process-enhanced stars known today.  We now have direct evidence that this hypothesis is indeed correct." Beers said

The concept of the r-process was first suggested in 1957. Astrophysicists theorized that the universe’s heaviest elements were formed after a set of high-energy explosive nucleosynthesis events occurred.   Recent evidence favors the suggestion that when merging binary neutron stars—the densest stars astronomers know of—collide, they can form the neutron-rich metals that account for the lower half of the period table, and spray them outward throughout the local environment. These metals become incorporated into the gas clouds of newly minted stars, which accounts for the presence of r-process elements in our sun, which formed billions of years ago. These same clouds can eventually form planets, like earth, where these heavy metals, including the silver, gold, and platinum, are also found.

Recent studies, including those by this group, have shown that neutron star mergers are not the only way the r-process elements are formed. However, the r-process-enhanced stars that can be studied to resolve this question are only found about 3-5 percent of the time among the already rare metal-poor halo stars, Beers said. The relatively low discovery rate means that large telescopes, which are expensive to operate and highly competitive to obtain time on, are not ideal for this search.  A breakthrough in finding them came when Beers and collaborators decided to use moderate-sized telescopes aimed at brighter metal-poor stars, so they could observe many more targets. Once identified as r-process-enhanced stars, these targets could then be observed at higher resolution with larger telescopes.

After using this multi-pronged approach to identify more than 400 r-process-enhanced stars, the research team began asking where these stars were born, based on their dynamics. Their latest discovery will enable future research into models of how our Milky Way’s chemistry changes over time, based on how many such dynamical groups of r-process-enhanced stars are found.

“Going forward we won’t have 30 of these groups, but hundreds,” Beers said, which will allow more opportunities for discovery of a shared chemical evolution history among stars.

In addition to Notre Dame researchers, collaborators included the Chinese Academy of Sciences, University of Sao Paulo, University of Michigan, the National Science Foundation’s (NSF’s) National Optical-Infrared Astronomy Research Laboratory, Rochester Institute of Technology, Texas A&M University, San Francisco State University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and the University of Florida.

The research was funded in part from grant PHY 14-30152, Physics Frontier Center/JINA Center for the Evolution of the Elements (JINA-CEE), awarded by the US National Science Foundation. 

Dmitrii Gudin
Dmitrii Gudin
Timothy Beers
Timothy Beers
Sarah Dietz
Sarah Dietz








Erika Holmbeck
Vini Placco
Kaitlin Rasmussen
Kaitlin Rasmussen








Derek Shank
Devin Whitten


Read the Full Paper